EmployeesoperateadrillingrigattheDaqingOilfieldinHeilongjiangprovince.[Photo/Xinhua]
Editor'snote:Oilpricesslidmorethan30percentovertheweekend,partlyduetothedifferencesbetweenSaudiArabiaandRussiaovercuttingproduction.ThesteepestdeclineinoilpricessincetheGulfWarin1991wasfollowedbyaroutonglobalstockmarkets,whichforcedtheUSstockmarkettohalttradingfor15minutesonMonday.ManyremainworrieddespiteareboundinoilpriceonTuesday.ThreeexpertssharetheirviewsonthedramaticdropinoilpricesfuturepricemovementswithChinaDaily'sLiuJianna.Excerptsfollow:
Lowpricestohurtalloilproducers
OilpriceshaveslumpedmainlybecauseoftheincreasinglydimglobalgrowthprospectsduetothenovelcoronavirusoutbreakandthefailedtalksbetweentheOrganizationofPetroleumExportingCountriesandnon-OPECexporters,especiallyRussia,tocutoutputtostabilizeprices.NowthatSaudiArabiahasdecidedtoincreaseproduction,thereisboundtobesurfeitsupply,whichcouldfurtherreduceoilprices.
Russiadidn'tagreetoSaudiArabia'sproposaltocutoutputbecause,ontheonehand,itfearsthatsuchamovewouldfurtherdecreaseitsoilrevenue,andontheother,ithopestorestraintheUSshaleoilandgasindustry'sdevelopment.
Assuch,oilpricescouldslidebelow$20abarrelintheshortterm.ButtheymayreboundinJunebywhenChinaislikelytoresumealmostnormalproductionandthecoronavirusoutbreakinEuropeisexpectedtoreachtheinflectionpoint.
LowoilpriceswouldsqueezetheUSshaleoilandgasindustry,whichinturnwillinfluenceglobaloilpricesandhelpstrikeanewbalanceinsupplyanddemand.AsforRussia,loweroilpriceswillreduceitsoverallrevenue,whichcouldcausepoliticalandsocialinstability.Therefore,loweroilpriceswoulddonogoodtoRussia,SaudiArabiaortheUnitedStates.SothekeyishowlongMoscowcancopewithlowoilprices.XiaYishan,aresearcherattheChinaInstituteofInternationalStudies
OilmarketmaystabilizeinJune
ThisMarch9,2020filephotoshowsamanwearingaprotectivefacemaskagainstthebackgroundofNahrBinUmaroilfield,whereflamesemergefromflarestacks.[Photo/Agencies]
Ifoilpricescouldnotbemaintainedatabout$50,itwouldbewiseofSaudiArabiatodecidetorampupitsoiloutputandofferdiscountstobuyersinEuropeandtheUSbecausedespiteitsmove,oilpriceswouldeventuallyrecoverbecauseofalikelynewbalanceindemandandsupply.
Besides,withaverylowproductioncostthatrangesfrom$5to$10abarrelandasizablecoffer,Riyadhcanaffordtoengageinapricewarforlongthroughsmallprofitsbutfastturnover.Bycontrast,Moscowisnotaswellplacedtofightapricewarduetoitshighproductioncostandlessfinancialresources.Thesignificantdepreciationoftheroubleinrecentdaysshouldgiveanindicationofitseconomicprowess.
ThatthemoveispartofaplottoweakentheUSshaleoilindustryisjustspeculation.EvenifthemovehalvestheUS'shalegasproduction,oilpriceswouldincreaseintheendbecauseofthedecreaseinsupplyresultingintheresumptionofnormalproductionofshalegas.
Mostpossibly,oilpriceswillbouncebackinJune,whenthecoronavirusoutbreakisexpectedtobecontainedleadingtoareboundindemand.LinBoqiang,headoftheChinaInstituteforStudiesinEnergyPolicyatXiamenUniversity.
Afinancialcrisiscan'tberuledout
Theslumpinoilpricesdidn'tcomeasasurprise,giventheovercapacityofmajoroilexportersandthefailureofthetalksbetweenOPECandnon-OPECcountriestocutoilproductionduetogloomyglobalgrowthprospects.ThetalkscollapsedbecauseSaudiArabiawantedtolifttheoilpricesbyreducingoutputwhileRussiadeemeditunnecessarytocutproductiondespitesluggishdemand.
Yet,tosomeextent,bothSaudiArabiaandRussiahopetodealablowtotheUS'shalegasindustrybyhelpingloweroilprices,inordertohaveabiggersayintheglobaloilmarketandgrabmoremarketshare.
ThestockmeltdownincountriesincludingtheUSreflectstheextremelylowgrowthexpectationsmainlyduetothenovelcoronavirusoutbreakandthereductioninoilprices.Soafinancialcrisiscannotberuledoutifthesituationdoesn'timproveandthespillovereffectofdisruptioninChina'ssupplychainaggravates.Ifthishappens,oilpricescouldfurthernosedive.
Furthermore,thepricewarbetweenSaudiArabiaandRussiamaydealadevastatingblowtorelativelysmallcountriesthatdependentirelyonoilexportssuchasLibya,AlgeriaandIraq.Also,theworseningeconomicprospectscouldexacerbatetheanti-governmentprotestsinthesecountries,whichcouldevenleadtoacivilwar.Andthewildfluctuationinoilpricesisexpectedtohaveanimpactontheirsecuritysituation.
ForChina,bothrelativelylowandhighpricesarenotgood.Asamajoroilconsumerandimporter,Chinadoesn'tfaceanoilshortage,andoilpriceshavebeenlowforquitesometime,soanynewreductioninpricesisnotexpectedtoboostgrowth,thoughhighpriceswouldhinderproduction.
AnddespitehurtingUSoilcompanies,loweroilpricescouldpropuptheUSeconomyandhelpmanufacturingunitsto"reshore",thatis,returntotheUS.
SunXia,anassociateresearchfellowattheInstituteofInternationalRelations,ShanghaiAcademyofSocialSciences